Arrow Icon Appears In Ketcher Sequence Mode Bug Report
Hey guys! We've got a bit of a situation on our hands with the Ketcher editor, specifically concerning the arrow icon behavior in different modes. It seems like there's a slight hiccup where the arrow icon is showing up in Sequence mode when it shouldn't be. Let's dive into the details and see what's going on.
Understanding the Issue: Arrow Icon in Sequence Mode
This bug report focuses on the unexpected appearance of the arrow icon in Ketcher's Sequence mode. According to the specifications, this icon should only be visible on hover in Snake and Flex modes. However, it's also showing up in Sequence mode, which isn't the intended behavior. This deviation from the requirements can lead to a confusing user experience, especially for those who rely on the distinct functionalities of each mode. To put it simply, the arrow icon is like that friend who shows up to the wrong party – helpful in the right place, but a bit out of context here. So, let's break down why this is happening and how it impacts the user experience. We'll walk through the steps to reproduce the issue and highlight the specific discrepancies between the actual and expected behavior. This will help us understand the scope of the bug and ensure we're all on the same page when discussing potential solutions. Our goal is to make Ketcher as intuitive and user-friendly as possible, and addressing this arrow icon issue is a step in the right direction. By clearly defining the problem and its impact, we can work towards a fix that aligns with the intended design and enhances the overall user experience.
Steps to Reproduce the Bug
To see this issue for yourself, follow these simple steps:
- Open the Ketcher editor in Sequence mode. This is the first and most crucial step. Make sure you're specifically in Sequence mode to observe the bug.
- Hover your mouse over any card in the sequence. The key action here is hovering, as the issue is related to the hover state of the card.
- Observe the left side of the card. You should see the arrow icon appear, which is the unexpected behavior we're addressing.
These steps are straightforward, making it easy for anyone to reproduce the bug and understand the issue firsthand. By following these instructions, you can confirm the presence of the arrow icon in Sequence mode and see how it deviates from the intended behavior. This helps in verifying the bug and ensuring that any proposed solutions effectively address the problem. Reproducing the bug is an important part of the bug reporting process, as it allows developers to accurately identify and fix the issue.
Actual vs. Expected Behavior: What's Going Wrong?
Actual Behavior: The arrow symbol appears on hover in Sequence mode, which is the core of the problem we're addressing. This means that when a user hovers their mouse over a card in Sequence mode, they see the arrow icon appear on the left side.
Expected Behavior: The arrow symbol should only appear on hover in Snake and Flex modes, as stated in the requirements. In Sequence mode, the arrow icon should remain hidden, maintaining the visual distinction between the modes. This clear separation helps users understand the specific functionality of each mode and avoid confusion. The unexpected appearance of the arrow icon in Sequence mode disrupts this intended clarity and can lead to a less intuitive user experience. By highlighting the difference between the actual and expected behavior, we can clearly define the scope of the bug and ensure that any fix accurately addresses the issue. This comparison also emphasizes the importance of adhering to the specifications and maintaining consistency across different modes in Ketcher. Ultimately, resolving this discrepancy will contribute to a more polished and user-friendly experience.
Requirement 1.2: The Rule We're Talking About
Let's get specific and call out the exact requirement that's being violated here. According to requirement 1.2:
“A new symbol, an arrow (⇐), should be added to the left side of the card, and appear only on hover of the card in snake and flex modes.”
This requirement clearly states that the arrow icon should only be visible in Snake and Flex modes. The fact that it's showing up in Sequence mode is a direct contradiction of this specification. By referencing this specific requirement, we can reinforce the validity of the bug report and provide a clear point of reference for developers working on a fix. It also underscores the importance of carefully reviewing and adhering to requirements during the development process. This ensures that the software behaves as intended and provides a consistent user experience across different features and modes. By highlighting the discrepancy between the actual behavior and the stated requirement, we can emphasize the need for a resolution and contribute to the overall quality of the Ketcher editor.
Visual Evidence: A Picture is Worth a Thousand Words
Here's a screenshot that clearly shows the issue:
The screenshot provides visual confirmation of the bug, making it easier for developers and other stakeholders to understand the issue. It clearly shows the arrow icon appearing on a card in Sequence mode, which is the unexpected behavior we're addressing. This visual evidence can be particularly helpful in cases where the bug might be difficult to describe or reproduce consistently. By including a screenshot, we can eliminate any ambiguity and ensure that everyone is on the same page regarding the nature of the problem. It also serves as a quick reference point during discussions and helps to streamline the bug-fixing process. In short, a picture can indeed be worth a thousand words when it comes to bug reporting, and this screenshot effectively illustrates the arrow icon issue in Ketcher's Sequence mode.
System Information: Digging into the Details
To help the developers track down the cause of this issue, here's some information about the system where the bug was observed:
- Operating System: Windows 11
- Browser: Chrome Version 138.0.7204.101 (Official Build) (64-bit)
- Ketcher version: Version 3.7.0-rc.1
- Indigo version: Version 1.35.0-rc.1
This system information is crucial for developers as they investigate and fix the bug. Knowing the specific operating system, browser version, and Ketcher/Indigo versions helps them narrow down the potential causes of the issue. For example, the bug might be specific to a particular browser version or operating system. By providing this detailed information, we can help the development team reproduce the bug in a controlled environment and identify the root cause more efficiently. This ultimately leads to a faster resolution and a more stable software product. In addition to the listed information, it's always a good idea to include any other relevant details, such as the user's screen resolution or any specific browser extensions that are enabled. The more information we provide, the better equipped the developers will be to tackle the problem.
Context: Where This Bug Was Found
This bug was discovered while testing a related issue: https://github.com/epam/ketcher/issues/3253
Providing the context in which the bug was found can be helpful for developers. It gives them a broader understanding of the situation and might reveal related issues or dependencies. In this case, the bug was discovered while testing another issue, which suggests that there might be an underlying connection between the two. This information can guide the developers in their investigation and help them identify the root cause of the problem. Additionally, knowing the context can help prioritize bug fixes based on their impact on other areas of the software. For example, if the bug is related to a critical feature or a recent change, it might warrant a higher priority. By including the context, we can contribute to a more efficient and effective bug-fixing process.
Conclusion: Let's Get This Fixed!
So, that's the scoop on the arrow icon showing up where it shouldn't be. Hopefully, this detailed report gives the development team everything they need to squash this bug. Keeping Ketcher consistent and user-friendly is key, and fixing this little visual glitch will definitely help! Let's work together to make Ketcher the best it can be!